I also considered the tacoma 05 and the tundra. Test drove them both. I have to say the tundra has an awesome carlike ride. Had it not been foir the price I would be driving a tundra right now. Reasons why I bought the T:
1: with the 1% apr and the below invoice price the T was a way better deal. I also wanted the VSC which is not available on 05 tacoma and tundra in minnesota. At least thats what the dealer told me,
2:Nissans have been good to me. Since 1994 my wife and I have owned 2 nissan pickups, two sedans my previous xterra and have never been to a repair shop
3: Although I love the impecable reputation of reliability of toyota the Tundra interior appeared dated, very few options for the price.
5: interior space. The T has'em beat there. No contest. The tacoma , although increased in size, still felt claustrophobic.
But then again, it depends on your particular situation. I have a family that will keep growing and need the space for the car seat. Of course in H.S you don't have those worries. If i were in high school( and could afford a new truck) I would probably go for smaller, economical tacoma. The tacoma is an awesome truck if you dont really need full size.
Good luck with your choice.
P.S. Man, what a dilemma for a high schooler: a choice b/t a brand new cool a$$ truck and another new C-A truck. My first car was a old beat up toyota hatchback, had to start it with a screw driver b/c the ignitiuon switch broke. Ohh, those were the days.
