I used the 12280 2"d/2.5"s, $78 shipped. Most people use the 12258 2.25"d/2.5"s, $62 shipped. Our stock muffler is 2.25"d/2.5"s but the pipes going in our 2" so I chose the 12280. Had I realized the 12258 was $16 cheaper I would've gotten that. I don't think there is any noticable performance difference, if any, between the 2. Now the Magnaflow inlets will be about 3-4" closer together than the stock inlets so in order for the stock pipes to fit the drivers side inlet was cut right before the curve about 18" form the muffler and rotated 180 degrees. Even then it still needed to bent slightly to line up. Of course everything is welded up, but any reputable muffler shop should be able to do this swap in less than an hour. Oh yeah, I ordered through hottexhaust, who probably beat anyone elses prices on Magnaflow products